"At one point, I went to a children's day fair and ended up sitting beside a rival politician. He was grasping a bundle of 100 baht notes to give away to the children, while I had arrived without gifts. How could I vie with that?"
Chutiphong Pipoppinyo was among the "progressive surge" of reform-minded newcomers who stunned Thailand in the 2023 election by capturing more seats for the progressive Move Forward party than any rival party.
This year though, he was defeated in his seat in his electoral district of Rayong to a challenger from an long-standing political dynasty which has historically held influential posts there.
"Back then we were akin to a hurricane that swept through and the established groups weren't ready to counter. They thought I was just a obscure candidate. The tide of support for Move Forward in the last phase of that election genuinely persuaded voters to try something new."
Now called the People's Party, their aspirations that they would build upon their earlier showing were dashed on the reefs of entrenched clientelist systems which have governed provincial politics in Thailand throughout its modern history.
The outcomes are still not official, and a number of election irregularities are being examined, but that cannot reverse the broad result: a steep drop of over 20% in the number of seats secured by the People's Party, and a notable rise by the conservative Bhumjaithai party, expanding its portion of seats from 71 in 2023 to an estimated 193 in the 500-seat parliament in the latest election.
'They never address me anymore'
Following securing his seat in 2023, Chutiphong threw himself into his position, travelling around his electoral area hoping to tackle the issues faced by his neighbours. But he quickly faced resistance from those aligned with the established political operators. Moreover, he found he was required to provide financial support, from money he did not have.
"I was invited to a women empowerment event - a frequent function for the residents to participate in and socialize. But they told me if I desired to come, I needed to give 25,000 baht. I explained I didn't have that money. They were extremely disappointed about that and said I was stingy. I inquired if there was something else I could do to help out. But they ignored me from then on."
What he had encountered was a deep-rooted framework of patronage dominated by a single family.
Rayong is best known as a component of the Eastern Economic Corridor, Thailand's major manufacturing hub, housing many of the factories which power its export-dependent economy. This has attracted outside workers from different areas, and also fostered an city-dwelling professionals which is more receptive to the change-oriented platforms of the new political wave.
In 2023, Move Forward secured all five electoral districts there.
But a significant portion of Rayong is still rural, the domain of agricultural workers and orchard owners. This is especially the case in District 4, where Chutipong claimed his seat. He is a local man, but lived time residing in California. The province has for many years been controlled by a prominent local household, the Pitutecha family. This is what is termed in Thailand as "Big House" – large household – politics, and across the country it is the method local power has always been exercised.
Pitutechas manage much of the municipal administration.
Piya 'Chang' Pitutecha, the present leading figure, is the selected chief of the Provincial Administration Organisation (PAO), a hugely influential position as the PAO controls the bulk of public funds in Rayong.
Until 2023, Pitutechas had invariably been included in the MPs voted to parliament, with one serving as the deputy health minister in Bangkok.
Like other "Big House" clans they have no fixed affiliation – over time they have stood for several political parties. They are also influential in the regional commercial sector, and, unlike Chutipong, have ample financial resources to distribute. It was virtually unfeasible for the rookie MP to contend.
The "Baan Yai" depend on widespread systems of canvassers - community members who know their villages, and who organize voters to support their candidate. And while it is officially prohibited, they also provide money before, during, and after elections. They have traditionally been critical to the success of regional candidates, and as a new, mostly urban movement, the People's Party had no access to them.
"So I changed my tactics," states Chutipong. "I announced that I would try to address all grievances immediately. If your water is cut off, your electricity has failed, your road has damage, I would assist."
"But the residents who sought my help then encountered intimidation from the local machine. Some got attacked in the village's chat group or over the PA system in the village. They were accused of allowing me - an intruder they said - into the area."
"On occasions when I attempted to inspect factories after receiving some reports about pollution, I faced a negative reaction from local communities because they had been accepting packets from these factories."
When it came to the latest election cycle, the Pitutechas had learned from their loss in the prior election.
In those electoral areas, they ran younger members of the family, with higher education and with a reduced godfather image than the older generation. In District 3 they ran under the Democrat party, traditionally their favored political partner, but in District 4, thirty-four-year-old Chatchai Pitutecha stood under Prime Minister Anutin Charvirakul's Bhumjaithai party, renowned for its wealth and its skill in gaining the support of "Baan Yai" for his side.
Chutipong was overwhelmed.
The Pitutechas won those positions back from the People's Party, while the progressives held onto three seats in Rayong.
"They might have welcomed me if I had provided them money, but I would not be able to do that forever due to my financial constraints. I had to choose whether I would be the MP they expected, or if I would keep my principles and find out if the voters would